Open letter: Alcohol health information labelling

Open letter:

As concerned clinicians, representatives of healthcare organisations and public health advocates we are calling on the Taoiseach and Minister for Health to ensure that the planned introduction in May 2026 of Ireland’s regulations on health information labelling of alcohol products is not derailed or delayed by alcohol industry lobbying.

These labels will ensure that consumers are given the facts about some of the risks from alcohol including risks in pregnancy, links with fatal cancers and liver disease.

This latest attempt from industry is part of a long-running campaign against these modest regulations. Previous efforts by the immensely profitable global alcohol industry have included claims that the warning language is “disproportionate and inaccurate,” and primarily geared toward “scaring people”. This is despite the evidence that even 1-2 drinks per day carries increased cancer risk with around 1000 alcohol related cancers diagnosed annually in Ireland, that liver disease death rates have steadily increased over the past 20 years and that Ireland has one of the highest rates of Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders in the world. 

The legislation for these warning labels was passed in 2018 after extensive debate and with support from right across the political spectrum, matched by ongoing strong public support of over 70% for the measure. Critically the debate was informed by the research base which was clearly articulated by multiple health experts and advocates, many with deep experience of the harms from alcohol. Since then, the evidence has only grown stronger. Ireland should take pride in its leadership in this regard. Like the smoking ban 20 years ago, it is likely that other countries will follow suit. 

In addition to the significant health reasons for these labels and the widespread support for them, there is also the issue of the impact of alcohol on the health service and the wider state. Alcohol costs the health service around 11% of its budget. The wider cost to the state including impacts on criminal justice and the loss of workplace productivity has been estimated by the World Health Organisation as at least 2.5% of GDP – €12 billion annually. Against this, alcohol excise duties only raise a tenth of this amount,  €1.2 billion annually. Reducing this burden must be an economic imperative for any government. 

With all of this in mind, it is essential that the public is provided with facts about alcohol as opposed to the spin from an immensely profitable, global industry which leaves the individuals, families and the State to pick up the tab for the damage its products cause.  The alcohol industry should have no influence on public health policy.    

Signatories:

Emma Balmaine, CEO, Irish Heart Foundation

Carol Fawsitt, former Chair, Alcohol Action Ireland, co-founder Silent Voices

Dr Sheila Gilheany, CEO, Alcohol Action Ireland

Paula Leonard, CEO, Alcohol Forum Ireland

Prof Frank Murray, Chair, Alcohol Health Alliance Ireland

Philip Watt, interim CEO, Mental Health Reform

Andy Ogle, Co-ordinator, North Eastern Regional Drug and Alcohol Taskforce

Averil Power, CEO, Irish Cancer Society

Dr Frank Houghton, Director, Social Sciences ConneXions, Technological University of the Shannon

Anthony Cotter, Dublin 6

Keith Cassidy, Clinic Manager, Smarmore Castle

Prof Tony Holohan, Director, WHO Collaborating Centre on One Health, University College Dublin

Prof Norah Campbell, Trinity Business School, TCD

Dr Siobhan Jennings, Specialist in Public Health Medicine (retired), RCPI

Alison Canavan, Coach and speaker, wellness advocate, AlisonCanavan.com

Donna Price, Founder and Chair, Irish Road Victims’ Association

Dr Ailbhe Smyth, former academic, patron of Silent Voices

Prof John Ryan, Consultant Hepatologist, Beaumont Hospital

Anne and John Higgins, Ballina, Co Mayo

Dr Cliona Saidléar, Executive Director, Rape Crisis Ireland

Dr Hugh Gallagher, HSE Integrated Alcohol Service, Addiction Services Dublin North

Siobhán McAndrew, Health Promotion & Improvement Officer, HSE

Lisa Corbett, Senior Community Nutritionist – Health Promotion, HSE West and North West

Prof  Sara Burke, Associate Professor and Director of the Centre for Health Policy, TCD

Prof Colin Doherty, Head of School of Medicine, TCD

Dr  Zubair Kabir, Senior Lecturer, School of Public Health, UCC

Dr Diarmuid O’Shea, President, Royal College of Physicians of Ireland

Adrienne Lynam, Health and Wellbeing Manager, Health Promotion and Improvement, HSE

David Lane, General Manager, Social Inclusion, HSE South West

Martina Mullin, Healthy Campus Manager, TCD

Prof Steve Thomas, Edward Kennedy Professor of Health Policy and Management, TCD

Dr Caitriona McCarthy, Consultant Public Health Medicine, National Cancer Control Programme, Irish Cancer Prevention Network

Dr Caroline Mason Mohan, Director of Public Health, National Screening Service, Irish Cancer Prevention Network

Orla Dolan, CEO, Breakthrough Cancer Research, Irish Cancer Prevention Network

Kevin O’Hagan, Cancer Prevention Manager, Irish Cancer Society, Irish Cancer Prevention Network

Liz Yeates, CEO, Marie Keating Foundation, Irish Cancer Prevention Network

Prof Noel McCarthy, Professor of Public Health Medicine, TCD

John Devlin, Chairperson, Addiction Counsellors of Ireland

Prof Susan Smith, Head of Discipline of Public Health and Primary Care, TCD 

Prof Lina Zgaga, Professor in Epidemiology, TCD

Dr Carlos Bruen, Course Director, MSc in Health Policy & Management, TCD

Prof Bobby Smyth, Clinical Pofessor, Dept of Public Health and Primary Care, TCD

Patricia Murphy, Director of Student Counselling, TCD

Dr David McGrath, Medical Director, College Health, TCD

Paddy Creedon, Chair, Voices of Recovery Alcohol Action Ireland

Marion Rackard, co-founder, Silent Voices Alcohol Action Ireland

Barbara Whelan, co-founder, Silent Voices Alcohol Action Ireland

Prof Catherine Darker, Professor in Health Services Research, TCD

Orlaith Kennedy, CEO, Dental Health Foundation Ireland

Suzanne Connolly, CEO, Barnardos

Fintan Foy, CEO, Irish College of GPs

Prof Jo-Hanna Ivers, Associate Professor in Addiction, TCD

Evelyn Fanning, Chairperson, Galway City Alcohol Forum

Prof John Ryan, Founding Director, Irish Liver Foundation

Orla Fagan, National Lead, Irish Community Action on Alcohol

Dr Anne Dee, President, Irish Medical Organisation

IHNA Committee, Irish Hepatology Nurse’s Association

John Church, CEO, ISPCC

Dr Gillian Shorter, Reader in Clinical Psychology, Queen’s University Belfast

Grace Hill, Coordinator, Tallaght Drugs and Alcohol Taskforce

Tanya Ward, CEO, Children’s Rights Alliance

Colin Fowler, Director of Operations, Men’s Health Forum in Ireland

Prof Stephen Stewart, Director of the Liver Centre, Mater Misericordiae University Hospital

Dr Eve Griffin, CEO, National Suicide Research Foundation

Andrea Ryder, Manager, Communication, External Affairs and Policy, College of Psychiatrists of Ireland

Hugh Greaves, Coordinator, Ballymun Local Drugs and Alcohol Task Force

Alex Bunting, Group Director of Therapuetic and Wellbeing Services, Inspire

Jennifer Moran Stritch, Applied Social Sciences/Social Sciences ConneXions Research Institute, Technological University of the Shannon, Limerick

Mike Taylor, Director of Policy & Public Affairs, FASD Ireland

Gemma O’Leary Short, CLDATF Development Worker, Cork Local Drug & Alcohol Task Force

Prof Colin O’Gara, Consultant Psychiatrist, Head of Addiction Services, Saint John of God University Hospital

Trevor Bisset, Coordinator, Clondalkin Drug and Alcohol Taskforce

Phillip Maree, Service Lead, Moving Parents and Children Together, M-PACT

Carol Moore, Trustee, Dual Diagnosis Ireland

Dr Breeda Neville, Specialist in Public Health Medicine, Irish Cancer Prevention Network

Angela King, Chair, Alcohol Sub-group/Building SAFER communities of Canals Communities Local Drug and Alcohol Taskforce

Total
0